Meritocracy - Short Cuts

Meritocracy - Short Cuts

Meritocracy The Uk Education system gives every student the same opportunity to do well. If they do not do well it is due to attitudes or intelligence Therefore the system is fair. Imagine this scenario- what are the problems 4 students all have similar intelligence are going to have a test on the achievements of Premier League football clubs in the South of England Student No 1 is dyslexic (boy) Student No 2 has just moved to the country (girl) Student No 3 is tired, hungry and upset (boy) What can you recall

about functionalism? Try and write down at least three things. If you get stuck, share ideas with a partner What do functionalists tell us about education and differences in attainment? Writers in the structural functionalist tradition of sociology claim that the education system is a meritocracy and that the education system exists to allow the most talented students through to fill the most important jobs in society.

Your current task is to assess that claim and to support your arguments with evidence Sociological Targets To understand functionalist views of education. To evaluate those views. To use sociological evidence and

research to support your judgements. Personal targets To write an essay length answer To contribute to whole class discussion in an orderly fashion To think critically about sociology explanations of inequality in

education What is functionalism? Functionalism is a consensus view of society. Functionalists believe that society is like an organism (organic analogy), with different parts fulfilling different roles to ensure survival of the whole. Functional sociologists tend to look at the mechanisms within society in order to

understand their functions for that society. Emile Durkheim Emile Durkheim was one of the founders of sociology. He believed we need schools to help us to feel part of society. We learn social rules and social roles in schools. Schools sort out people for the most appropriate jobs for their skills and abilities.

What is meritocracy? Functionalist say the education system acts as a ladder of opportunity for people to achieve the best that they can, according to their ability. The best people go on to gain the best jobs and become the leaders of their society. This belief is known as meritocracy. Talcott Parsons

Talcott Parsons is a well-known American theorist. Parsons developed StructuralFunctionalist theory. Parsons suggests schools are an agency of secondary socialisation. They train children to accept the norms and values of wider society. They act to select which children will be trained for the top jobs in society. They teach children that the system is fair and equal to all.

Davis and Moore (1945) Inequality is necessary and universal because all societies have inequalities. If inequality exists, then it must be because it is for the good of society. This justifies the high pay and status of the richest people in society.

What is evaluation? Evaluation is the process of judging the value of a research project, an idea or a concept, using further concepts, studies and theories to support the judgement that is made. Strengths and weaknesses are identified in an evaluation What are the strengths of functionalism?

It points to links between and within social institutions in society It emphasises the importance of socialisation within schools It influences New Right thinking and research And the weaknesses?

It justifies inequality There is little supporting evidence People do not all share norms and values It ignores structural inequalities such

as racism, sexism and social class A famous challenge Alvin Gouldner wrote in the 1970s at the height of student rioting against the Vietnam War. He said: According to Parsons, people who do not fit in are deviant. How come it was most intelligent students who were deviant enough to complain

about the war, the lack of equality and who challenged traditional ways of thinking? Outline and assess functional views of education. Criteria for success Outline functionalism

Outline what the theorists say Assess the strengths of functionalist thinking Assess the weakness of functionalist thinking. Refer to AO1 knowledge about the educational system of the UK Use the concepts of sociology Refer to studies, writers or theory in your answer. Use evaluative language in your answer Outline the meaning of the term Meritocracy (equality of opportunity)

Explain the term Reasons why education is meritocratic Counter-argued with reasons why it is not meritocratic Meritocracy is a Functionalist idea Marxists would argue it is a myth Use evidence ! Keywords ! And dont forget your AO2s

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Biological Sciences 318- Parasitology Lab Platyhelminthes - Cestodes

    Biological Sciences 318- Parasitology Lab Platyhelminthes - Cestodes

    Biological Sciences 318- Parasitology Lab Platyhelminthes - Cestodes Kingdom: Animalia (unranked): Protostomia (unranked): Spiralia (unranked): Platyzoa Phylum: Platyhelminthes Characteristics: 1) simplest bilaterally symmetrical animals 2) 3 layers fundamental cell layers (ectoderm, endoderm, mesoderm) 3) body contains no internal cavity 4)...
  • MARCC: Update FY18 Jaime E. Combariza 2018 IDIES

    MARCC: Update FY18 Jaime E. Combariza 2018 IDIES

    Additionally, MARCC is also used to for a development project to improve the current pipeline for calling mtDNA-CN and heteroplasmy from sequencing data. Alignment of sequence reads to the circular mitochondrial genome currently treats the mtDNA as a linear piece...
  • Diferentes Visões da Avaliação

    Diferentes Visões da Avaliação

    Adoção de taxonomias de objetivos e métodos de descrição de objetivos educacionais (Mager e Mager e Pipe). O uso de abordagens centradas em objetivos Início na década de 30 nos EUA e em outros países. Refinada por Mager (1962): formulação...
  • I Wish Id Said That PLAGIARISM, QUOTING, &

    I Wish Id Said That PLAGIARISM, QUOTING, &

    Bradley & Fritts. Once the regression coefficients have been calculated, the eigenvectors incorporated in the regression equation are mathematically transformed into a new set of n coefficients corresponding to the original (intercorrelated) set of n variables.These new coefficientsare termed weights...
  • Review of Project-Based Learning in a Junior Level

    Review of Project-Based Learning in a Junior Level

    Wind Tubine Gear Box Project. Using the same report format students will: Create overall assembly drawing that shows each component in place. Gearing Specification & Selection. Determine the forces on the gears to find the bearing loads. Specify commercial bearing...
  • Prepay Energy Working Group - Michigan

    Prepay Energy Working Group - Michigan

    Prepay Energy is Growing Rapidly and Part of Mega Trend. Prepay is a mega trend in consumer finance. TransCard projects that prepayments from all segments (consumer, commercial and public) will total $421 billion in transactions in 2017.
  • Cost-Benefit Analysis Training: APS Case Study Version 6.1

    Cost-Benefit Analysis Training: APS Case Study Version 6.1

    We will prepare our cost estimate for COA #1 for the years FY12-19. This happens to represent the POM cycle (and it fits well on the slide). For lifecycle costs our estimate must extend through the entire lifecycle of the...
  • Reflecting on Practice: Worthwhile Tasks

    Reflecting on Practice: Worthwhile Tasks

    1. Find the area of right triangles, other triangles, special quadrilaterals, and polygons by composing into rectangles or decomposing into triangles and other shapes; apply these techniques in the context of solving real world and mathematical problems. Reflecting on Practice....