Morality and Practical Reason: Kant

Morality and Practical Reason: Kant

Chapter 7: Ethics Morality and Practical Reason: Kant Introducing Philosophy, 10th edition Robert C. Solomon, Kathleen Higgins, and Clancy Martin Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) German philosopher, probably the greatest philosopher since Plato and Aristotle Lived his entire life in a small town in East

Prussia (Konigsburg); was a professor at the university there for more than thirty years Never married; neighbors said that his habits were so regular that they could set their watches by him (a later German poet said, It is hard to write about Kants life, for he had no life) Yet, from a safe distance, Kant was one of the most persistent defenders of the French Revolution and, in philosophy,

created no less a revolution himself His philosophical system, embodied in three huge volumes called Critique of Pure Reason (1781), Critique of Practical Reason (1788), and Critique of Judgment (1790), changed the thinking of philosophers as much as the revolution changed France His central thesis is the defense of what he calls synthetic a priori judgments (and their moral and

religious equivalents) by showing their necessity for all human experience In this way, he escapes from Humes skepticism and avoids the dead-end intuitionism of his rational predecessors Kants Ethics: The Basics Morality must be based solely on reason. Its central concept is the concept of duty (dein), and so morality is a matter of deontology Morality must be autonomous, a function of

individual reason, such that every rational person is capable of finding out what is right and what is wrong for himself or herself All personal feelings, desires, impulses, and emotions are inclinations. Morality is independent of inclination The Good Will Kant begins by saying that what is ultimately good is a good will. And a good will, in turn, is the will that exercises pure practical reason What we will, that is, what we try to do, is

wholly within our control. And reason serves the purpose of instructing our will in our duty. The notion of duty includes that of a good will A good will subjects itself to rational principles. Those rational principles are moral laws, and it is action in accordance with such laws that alone makes a person good The Categorical Imperative(s) The general formulation of Kants notion

of duty is the categorical imperative Categorical imperatives demand that one simply do this or dont do this, whatever the circumstances The word that distinguishes moral commands in general is the word ought, and categorical imperatives tell us what we ought to do, independent of circumstances or goals There is therefore but one categorical imperative, namely, this: Act only on that

maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law Moral or categorical imperatives provide universal laws that tell us what to do in every circumstance. With hypothetical imperatives, on the other hand, what is commanded depends upon particular circumstances A maxim, according to Kant, is a subjective principle of action, or what we would call an intention. It is

distinguished from an objective principle, that is, a universal law of reason The categorical imperative is an a priori principle: Necessary Independent of particular circumstances True for all rational beings Objections to Kants Conception of Morality It may be too strict: the idea that

morality and duty have nothing to do with our personal desires or inclinations seems to make the moral life undesirable Kants emphasis on the categorical imperative systematically rules out all reference to particular situations and circumstances, but the right thing to do is often determined by the particular context or situation Kant gives us no adequate way of

choosing between moral imperatives that conflict. The rule that tells us don't lie! is categorical; so is the rule that tells us keep your promises! Suppose that I promise not to tell anyone where you will be this weekend. Then some people wishing to kill you try to force me to tell. Either I break the promise, or I lie. Kant gives us no solution to this moral conflict

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Who? What? When?

    Who? What? When?

    Word and Excel - if not complete, speak with Dr.Peterson before or after class. Library - done as Homework #2 --- details in Notes for Week 6 on class web site (due today --- if not done, bring it late,...
  • First Part of 1.2 - Texas Tech University

    First Part of 1.2 - Texas Tech University

    Managers noticed that consumers no longer wanted to buy pens or paper in bulk. So the company created displays to sell individual sharpies and small packs of paper, which proved successful. ... then the strategy may need to be modified....


    Pictorial depth cues: clues about distance that can be given in a flat picture. Includes linear perspective, texture gradients, interposition, relative size, height in plane, and light and shadow. PERCEPTUAL CONSTANCIES IN VISION.
  • Pathogens - CEE Cornell

    Pathogens - CEE Cornell

    Public Health Implications of Water Supply Improvements Did Environmental Engineers save the world? Review: Public Health Implications of Water Supply Improvements The life expectancy transition The role of water supply, sanitation, and hygiene In the Global North a century ago...


    images of colorimetric reactions induced by air plasma in . KI-Starch (tap water) solution. DOE Plasma Science Center. Control of Plasma Kinetics. Iodide is oxidized into iodine via advanced oxidation processes initiated by ROS generated by air plasma. Iodine is...
  • BTEC Health & Social Care Level - Holy cross college health ...

    BTEC Health & Social Care Level - Holy cross college health ...

    Gesell's Maturation theory . Arnold Gesell looked into children's . biological maturation . around the 1940's - 1950's. He developed the ' normative approach ' by observing large numbers of children to find the skills and abilities that most children...
  • Cell Structure - MISS PASCIAK'S BIOLOGY

    Cell Structure - MISS PASCIAK'S BIOLOGY

    STERNGRR processes occur in cells! All cells come from pre-existing cells. Cells reproduce to make more cells. Bacteria. ALL cells have. DNA (chromosomes) Cytoplasm. Ribosomes. Cell membrane (aka plasma membrane) Prokaryotic Cells. Ribosomes. DNA . Cell Membrane.
  • Phases of Matter and Energy -

    Phases of Matter and Energy -

    PHASE diagram vs. heating curve. Phase diagram. Heating curve. Pressure - y axis. Temperature - x axis. Shows all 6 phase changes. Shows equilibrium temperatures and pressures for all phase changes. Temperature - y axis. Heat over time - x...